Don't Let a Great Hiring Year Fool You
This is where we'd get quite nosy.
Candidate one
Increased hiring by 40% while reducing agency spend. Great. Now imagine the company had just become one of the hottest employers in its sector, applications were pouring in and hiring managers had been given additional interview support.
Candidate two
Delivered a smaller improvement while opening a new market, with almost no employer recognition and a hiring team they were still building.
Those are not remotely the same achievement.
With senior TA candidates, we'd want to understand what the market was giving them for free. Were candidates already interested? Were salaries competitive? Did hiring managers prioritise recruitment?
The numbers still matter. We just want to know how much work the TA leader had to do to create them.
| The Result Sounds Good | What We’d Still Want to Know |
|---|---|
| Reduced time-to-hire | Where was the time actually taken out — sourcing, interviews, approvals or offers? |
| Cut agency spend | Did they build internal sourcing capability, negotiate differently or simply recruit less that year? |
| Increased hiring volume | Did the existing team become more productive, did headcount increase or did the hiring itself become easier? |
| Improved offer acceptance | What changed — candidate management, compensation, speed or the proposition itself? |
| Rolled out a new ATS | What became measurably easier or better once it was live? |
A percentage without the story behind it can make two very different TA leaders look remarkably similar.